Two elderly women in Kostanay fell victim to phone scammers and lost a combined 23.5 million tenge, while the only defendant to stand trial was sentenced to six years in prison, the website infohub.kz reports.
According to the Telegram channel "Topical News of Cassation Courts," one of the pensioners was told by phone that her granddaughter had been in a traffic accident, while the other was told that her daughter had caused a crash. The women were persuaded to hand over money so that their relatives would avoid criminal liability.
A man came to collect the cash. He introduced himself to one of the victims under a fictitious name, Rustam. He visited the other twice, claiming the amount she had handed over was not enough. The total damage amounted to 23.5 million tenge.
The court of first instance found the man guilty under Article 190, Part 4, Paragraph 2 of the Criminal Code and sentenced him to six years in prison for large-scale fraud. The appellate court upheld the ruling.
In his cassation appeal, the convicted man disputed the existence of a prior conspiracy and the amount of the damage, claiming he had acted only as a courier.
The cassation court rejected the argument that the man was unaware of the deception. In both episodes, he collected the cash immediately after the victims were persuaded to hand over the money, counted it, transferred it to various accounts, reported the transfers to an accomplice and received a share of the stolen funds. Taken together, these circumstances confirmed that he acted in a pre-assigned role.
The court verified the disputed amount in the second episode against the testimony of the victim and a witness, documents and the ruling on compensation for damages. It came to 22 million tenge, which exceeded the threshold for especially large-scale fraud. As a result, the cassation court for criminal cases left the judicial acts unchanged.


